Skip to content

Do we live in 'No Man's Land?'

Liberal MPP refers to northern Ontario as 'No Man’s Land'
North Bay, Ontario.

NORTH BAY - A comment yelled out by Liberal member Lou Rinaldi Thursday in the Ontario Legislature has the opposition pouncing.

During a speech by Parry Sound-Muskoka MPP Norm Miller on the north, Rinaldi, speaking off camera, heckled Miller by referring to the region as “No Man’s Land.”

The comment was immediately caught by PC MPP Sam Oosterhoff on the floor of the legislature.

“As I was listening to this debate, I heard the member for Northumberland–Quinte West heckling the member here. When the member was speaking about the fact that our leader has visited the north 27 times and the fact that our caucus is making an effort to reach out to those in the north and to build a stronger connection with those in the north, the member for Northumberland–Quinte West yelled out that 'the north is a no man’s land,' and that’s why we (the PCs) go there.

"I don’t know, I found that very insulting, quite frankly. I don’t think the north is a no man’s land. I think we’ve heard that the north is a very important part of our province that contributes to the socio-economic culture of our province in significant ways. We should treasure the north. We should celebrate the north, and we should be doing everything we can to build the north up. Quite frankly, I was disappointed to hear that sentiment from the government benches.”

Since facing backlash at Queen’s Park, Rinaldi admitted making the statement but says he was attacking Vic Fedeli’s comments.  

"It’s a puzzling excuse given that Norm Miller, not Vic Fedeli, was speaking at the time," says a PC news release.

See Oosteroff's response here.


Jeff Turl

About the Author: Jeff Turl

Jeff is a veteran of the news biz. He's spent a lengthy career in TV, radio, print and online, covering both news and sports. He enjoys free time riding motorcycles and spoiling grandchildren.
Read more